Welcome to Mary’s Fireside Inn

Mary’s Fireside Take Out Menu

All Items availabe regular or gluten free.  All orders must be prepaid. Call 716-592-9979 to place your order.


Bacon Wrapped Scallops

served with honey mustard sauce 10.99

Coconut Shrimp

served with mandarin orange marmalade 10.99

Mozzarella Sticks

served with marinara 6.99

Smoked Banana Pepper Dip

house smoked banana peppers with three cheeses, served with tortilla chips or crostini 10.99

Soup du Jour

cup 3.79/bowl 4.99

French Onion au Gratin

crostini, provolone and swiss 6.59

Sandwiches, Fingers, and Wings

Prime Rib Sandwich

thin sliced, roasted prime rib of beef with provolone cheese on a kaiser roll served with house cut french fries 11.99

Fireside Grilled Cheese Sandwich

Three cheeses, apple slices and our house

made bacon jam served on marble rye bread with house cut french fries 10.99

Reuben Sandwich

House brined corned beef, sauerkraut, swiss cheese and 1000 Island dressing our marble rye with house cut french fries 10.99

Chicken Tenders

served with fresh house cut french fries

9.99 for three/ 16.99 for six

Jumbo Chicken Wings

9.99 for 10/17.99 for 20

hot, medium, mild, bbq

Specialty Sauces for Wings and Fingers

(1.00/2.00): cajun, garlic parmesan,

honey mustard, italian herb,

sweet thai chili, maple garlic, spicy maple

extra blue cheese 2.00

Add $2. for split sauce


Quarter Pound Burger 7.99

Half Pound Burger 11.99


Chicken Parmesan

breaded chicken breast, marinara, spaghetti, provolone and paremesan cheese 14.99


house made marinara sauce served over spaghetti noodles 9.99

Meatball 3.00 Italian Sausage 5.00

NY Strip Steak

12 ounce Choice NY Strip Steak seasoned with our house rub, served with house made steak sauce 22.99

NY Strip Steak

8 ounce choice NY Strip Steak seasoned with our house rub, served with house made steak sauce


Ribeye Steak

12 ounce Choice Ribeye seasoned with our house rub and served with house made steak sauce 22.99

Chicken Breast

Roasted chicken breast in a rosemary,

lemon, white wine reduction 15.99


baked with shallot butter and white wine 22.99


oven roasted salmon with a maple glaze

featuring Wendel’s Maple Sugar 17.99

Fishfry will be available on Friday!

Mac n Cheese will be available on Saturday!


Creme Brulee 4

Vanilla bean custard with a crisp sugar top

Chocolate Lava Cake 3

Chocolate cake with a hot fudgy center

Decadent Brownie 2


Bottled Pop, Bottled Beer, Draft Beer, and Wine

Call 716-592-9979 to order.

Fish Fry Every Friday!

Fisherman's Platter Shrimp, scallops and Cod Available regular or gluten free

Seafood Platter
Shrimp, Scallops and Cod
Available regular or gluten free on Fridays only.

The Fireside Inn is one of Western New York’s hidden jewels, serving dinners in a relaxed, casual atmosphere of an 1840′s farmhouse.

                                         Open Sunday  12:00 pm  ~ 7:00 pm. Wednesday ~ Friday  4:00 pm  to 9 pm. Saturday 12:00 pm  ~ 9:00 pm. (Kitchen closes a half hour before the restaurant).  Closed Monday and Tuesdays.